How Effective Are Broom Vacuums In Comparison To Traditional Vacuums?

When it comes to keeping your living space tidy and free of dust and debris, the choice of a vacuum cleaner plays a crucial role. In this article, we will explore the effectiveness of broom vacuums in comparison to their traditional counterparts. With the aim of providing you with a comprehensive understanding, we will examine factors such as cleaning performance, convenience, and versatility. By the end of this article, you’ll have a clearer perspective on whether a broom vacuum is the right choice for your cleaning needs.

Cleaning Power and Performance

When it comes to cleaning power, traditional vacuums are often seen as the powerhouse of the cleaning world. However, broom vacuums have come a long way in recent years and are now more capable than ever before.

Suction Power

Traditional vacuums typically boast stronger suction power, thanks to their larger motors and design. This makes them ideal for deep cleaning carpets and removing embedded dirt and debris. Broom vacuums, on the other hand, have smaller motors but still offer impressive suction for their size. While they may not match the suction power of their traditional counterparts, they are more than capable of effectively cleaning hard floors and low-pile carpets.

Surface Coverage

When it comes to surface coverage, traditional vacuums often excel due to their wider cleaning paths. This allows for faster cleaning of larger areas, such as living rooms or bedrooms. Broom vacuums, on the other hand, tend to have narrower cleaning heads, making them better suited for smaller spaces or hard-to-reach areas. However, many broom vacuums come with swivel heads that allow for easy maneuverability and access to tight corners and under furniture.

Pickup Efficiency

Both traditional vacuums and broom vacuums differ in their pickup efficiency. Traditional vacuums are typically designed with a brush roll that agitates carpet fibers, helping to loosen dirt and debris for better pickup. Broom vacuums, on the other hand, often rely on suction alone to pick up dirt and debris from hard surfaces. While this may seem less effective, the suction power of broom vacuums combined with their lightweight design allows for easy maneuverability and thorough pickup of dirt and debris on hard floors.

Convenience and Ease of Use

Cleaning should be a convenient and hassle-free task, and both traditional vacuums and broom vacuums strive to provide just that. However, there are certain factors to consider when it comes to the convenience and ease of use of both types of vacuums.


Traditional vacuums can be heavy and bulky, making them more difficult to maneuver around the house, especially when it comes to navigating stairs or tight spaces. Broom vacuums, on the other hand, are lightweight and often cordless, allowing for effortless movement and easy navigation. Their slim design and swivel heads make it a breeze to clean around furniture legs and other obstacles.

Size and Weight

Traditional vacuums are typically larger and heavier, which can make them challenging to use for longer periods. Broom vacuums, on the other hand, are compact and lightweight, making them easier to handle and carry around. This feature is especially beneficial for individuals with limited mobility or strength, as it reduces strain and fatigue during cleaning sessions.

Noise Level

Noise can be a significant factor when choosing a vacuum, especially if you live in an apartment or have noise-sensitive pets or family members. Traditional vacuums tend to be louder due to their larger motors and more substantial build. Broom vacuums, on the other hand, are generally quieter and produce less noise during operation, allowing for a more peaceful cleaning experience.

Cordless vs Corded

One of the main differences between traditional vacuums and broom vacuums is the power source. Traditional vacuums are typically corded, requiring an electrical outlet for operation. This limitation can limit movement and make it challenging to clean larger areas. Broom vacuums, on the other hand, are often cordless, powered by rechargeable batteries. This freedom of movement allows for more flexibility and convenience during cleaning sessions, without the need to maneuver around cords or switch outlets.

Versatility and Multi-functionality

While cleaning floors is a primary task for both traditional vacuums and broom vacuums, their versatility and multi-functionality can vary.

Attachments and Accessories

Traditional vacuums often come with a wide range of attachments and accessories, such as crevice tools, upholstery brushes, and motorized brush heads. These attachments allow for more precise cleaning of different surfaces and hard-to-reach areas. Broom vacuums, on the other hand, may have fewer attachments but still offer practical tools like crevice tools and brush attachments for above-floor cleaning.

Floor Compatibility

Traditional vacuums are designed to handle various floor types, including carpets, rugs, hardwood, and tile. With adjustable brush settings and height adjustments, they can effectively clean different surfaces without causing damage. Broom vacuums, on the other hand, are more suitable for hard floors, low-pile carpets, and rugs. While they may not have the same versatility as traditional vacuums, they excel in quick and efficient cleaning of hard surfaces.

Above-floor Cleaning

When it comes to above-floor cleaning, traditional vacuums with their range of attachments often provide more flexibility. Whether it’s vacuuming upholstery, curtains, or hard-to-reach corners and ceiling cobwebs, traditional vacuums can tackle these tasks with ease. Broom vacuums, while not as versatile, can still be used for above-floor cleaning, particularly with the help of additional attachments and tools.

Battery Life and Charging Time

For cordless broom vacuums, battery life and charging time are crucial factors to consider.

Battery Capacity

The battery capacity of broom vacuums varies between models, with some offering longer battery life than others. Higher-end broom vacuums often feature larger-capacity batteries, allowing for more extended cleaning sessions without the need for recharging. Lower-end models may have smaller batteries, which may require more frequent charging.


The runtime of a broom vacuum refers to the duration it can clean continuously on a single charge. This can range from 15 minutes to over an hour, depending on the model and battery capacity. It’s important to consider your cleaning needs and the size of your home when evaluating the runtime of a broom vacuum.

Recharge Time

Recharge time refers to the amount of time required to fully charge the battery of a cordless broom vacuum. This can vary depending on the model and battery capacity. Some broom vacuums can be fully charged in as little as 2 hours, while others may take up to 4 hours. Considering the recharge time is important to ensure that the vacuum is ready for use when you need it.

Dust Collection and Filtration

The dust collection and filtration systems of both traditional vacuums and broom vacuums play a crucial role in maintaining a clean and healthy home environment.

Bagged vs Bagless

Traditional vacuums often use a bagged system to collect dust and debris. The bags can be easily removed and replaced, ensuring that the collected dirt is sealed and contained. Broom vacuums, on the other hand, mostly employ a bagless system, using dust canisters or bins to collect dirt and debris. These canisters are easily emptied and provide the convenience of not needing to purchase replacement bags. However, they may require frequent emptying and can release some dust back into the air during disposal.

Dust Capacity

Traditional vacuums with their larger size often have larger dust capacities, allowing for more extended cleaning sessions without the need for emptying. Broom vacuums, due to their smaller size, typically have smaller dust canisters that may require more frequent emptying, especially during thorough cleaning sessions. It’s important to consider the dust capacity of a vacuum in relation to the size of your home and cleaning needs.

HEPA Filtration

HEPA filtration is an essential feature to consider, particularly for individuals with allergies or asthma. Traditional vacuums often come equipped with HEPA filters, which are capable of capturing small particles and allergens, preventing them from being released back into the air. Many broom vacuums also offer HEPA filtration, ensuring cleaner and healthier indoor air quality.

Maintenance and Cleaning

Both traditional vacuums and broom vacuums require regular maintenance and cleaning to ensure optimal performance. Traditional vacuums may require more maintenance, such as cleaning or replacing brush rolls, belts, and filters. Broom vacuums, on the other hand, often have simpler maintenance requirements, such as emptying dust canisters and cleaning filters. It’s important to follow the manufacturer’s instructions for maintenance and cleaning to keep your vacuum in top shape.

Price and Affordability

The price of a vacuum can vary widely based on its features, brand, and performance. It’s important to consider both the initial cost and long-term expenses when evaluating the affordability of a vacuum.

Initial Cost

Traditional vacuums are often more expensive than broom vacuums due to their larger size and additional features. Higher-end traditional vacuums from reputable brands can command a premium price tag. Broom vacuums, while generally more affordable, can still vary in price depending on the brand, performance, and features offered. It’s essential to consider your budget and cleaning needs when evaluating the initial cost of a vacuum.

Long-term Expenses

In addition to the initial cost, long-term expenses should be taken into account when purchasing a vacuum. This includes the cost of replacement bags for traditional vacuums, as well as the cost of filters or other maintenance items for both traditional and broom vacuums. It’s important to consider these ongoing expenses to ensure that your vacuum remains cost-effective in the long run.

Durability and Longevity

Durability and longevity are crucial factors to consider when investing in a vacuum cleaner.

Build Quality

Traditional vacuums are often built with heavy-duty materials and robust construction, making them more durable and capable of withstanding the rigors of regular use. Broom vacuums, while typically not as robust as their traditional counterparts, can still offer durable construction with high-quality materials. It’s important to consider the build quality of a vacuum to ensure that it can withstand the demands of your cleaning tasks.

Warranty Coverage

A warranty can provide peace of mind and protection against any potential defects or malfunctions. Traditional vacuums often come with longer warranty periods, typically ranging from 3 to 5 years. Broom vacuums, on the other hand, may have shorter warranty periods, ranging from 1 to 3 years. It’s important to check the warranty coverage provided by the manufacturer and consider any additional warranty options available for purchase.

Environmental Impact

With increasing awareness of environmental concerns, it’s essential to consider the environmental impact of the vacuum cleaner you choose.

Energy Efficiency

Traditional vacuums often consume more energy due to their larger motors and more powerful suction. Broom vacuums, with their smaller motors and streamlined design, tend to be more energy-efficient. Look for vacuums that have high energy efficiency ratings to minimize your overall energy consumption.

Material and Component Recycling

When it comes to the end of a vacuum’s life cycle, it’s important to consider the recyclability of its materials and components. Traditional vacuums often contain a larger number of components that may need to be disassembled before recycling. Broom vacuums, with their simpler designs, may be easier to recycle. Look for brands that actively promote and facilitate recycling initiatives to minimize the environmental impact of your vacuum.


Another environmental consideration is the emissions produced during vacuuming. Traditional vacuums, especially those without HEPA filters, can release small particles and allergens back into the air during operation. Broom vacuums with HEPA filters can provide cleaner and healthier indoor air by trapping these particles. Choosing a vacuum with superior filtration capabilities can minimize the emissions and improve indoor air quality.

Customer Reviews and Satisfaction

While assessing the technical aspects of vacuums is important, customer reviews and satisfaction can provide valuable insights and real-world experiences to guide your decision-making process.

Positive Feedback

Reading positive reviews can give you confidence in the performance, reliability, and features of a vacuum. Look for reviews that highlight the strengths and benefits of the vacuum, such as exceptional suction power, ease of use, and durability. Positive feedback can serve as an indication that the vacuum is likely to meet your cleaning needs and expectations.

Negative Feedback

Negative reviews can provide valuable information on potential issues or limitations of a vacuum. Common complaints may include short battery life, weak suction power, or poor durability. Pay attention to recurring negative feedback to identify any significant drawbacks or shortcomings of a vacuum that may impact your satisfaction.


In conclusion, broom vacuums have come a long way in terms of cleaning power and performance, convenience and ease of use, versatility and multi-functionality, battery life and charging time, dust collection and filtration, price and affordability, durability and longevity, environmental impact, and customer reviews and satisfaction. While traditional vacuums still offer superior cleaning power and versatility, broom vacuums have their own advantages such as maneuverability, lightweight design, and cordless convenience. Your choice between a traditional vacuum and a broom vacuum ultimately depends on your specific cleaning needs, preferences, and budget. Consider the various factors outlined in this article and weigh them against your requirements to make an informed decision. Happy cleaning!